"Sincerely, Me" (Reprise)
Connor, Jared

"To Break in a Glove"
Larry, Evan

"Only Us"
Zoe, Evan

"Good for You"
Heidi, Alana, Jared, Evan

"You Will Be Found" (Reprise)
Company

"Words Fail"
Evan

"So Big/So Small"
Heidi

"Finale"
Company