“I Didn’t Plan It”
Becky 

“Bad Idea” (Reprise)
Company 

“You Matter to Me”
Dr. Pomatter and Jenna 

“I Love You Like a Table”
Ogie, Dawn, and Company 

“Take It From an Old Man”
Joe and Company 

“She Used to Be Mine”
Jenna 

“Everything Changes”
Jenna and Company 

“Opening Up” (Finale)
Company