Act One
| Song | Show |
| Welcome to the Rock | Come From Away |
| Heaven on their Minds | Jesus Christ Superstar |
| I Dreamed a Dream | Les Misérables |
| Dust and Ashes |
Natasha, Pierre, and the Great Comet of 1812 |
| Tomorrow | Annie |
| The Hills are Alive | Sound of Music |
| Music of the Night | Phantom of the Opera |
| I Can Hear the Bells | Hairspray |
| Anything You Can Do | Annie Get Your Gun |
| Popular | Wicked |
| She's In Love | Little Mermaid Jr. |
| Corner of the Sky | Pippin |
| Found Tonight | Hamilton/Dear Evan Hansen |
Act Two
| Song | Show |
| What's Inside/Opening Up | Waitress |
| Memory | Cats |
| Don't Rain on my Parde | Funny Girl |
| Santa Fe | Newsies |
| Quiet | Matilda |
| It's Not Over Yet | Parade |
| Brotherhood of Man | How to Succeed |
| Stranger | Big Fish |
| I Feel Pretty | West Side Story |
| Agony | Into the Woods |
| I'm Not Afraid of Anything | Songs for a New World |
| Freak Flag | Shrek Jr |