- Overture
- Heaven on Their Minds - Judas
- What’s the Buzz? – Jesus, Mary Magdalene, Ensemble
- Strange Thing Mystifying – Judas, Jesus, Ensemble
- Everything’s Alright – Mary Magdalene, Judas, Apostles
- This Jesus Must Die – Annas, Caiaphas, Priests, Mob
- Hosanna – Jesus, Crowd, Caiaphas
- Simon Zealotes/Poor Jerusalem – Jesus, Simon, Ensemble
- Pilate’s Dream – Pilate
- The Temple – Jesus, Girl, Boy, Lepers, Crowd
- Everything Alright (Reprise) – Mary Magdalene, Jesus
- I Don’t Know How to Love Him – Mary Magdalene
- Damned For All Time/Blood Money – Judas, Caiaphas, Annas, Ensemble