Ralph Vaughan Williams Four Last Songs are the product of a decades-long creative partnership with his second wife, Ursula Wood Vaughan Williams. Ursula, a poet and author, first met Ralph in 1938 after she had written to him to suggest that he compose music for a ballet. Their first face-to-face meeting over lunch led to lengthy discussions of poetry, and eventually a close personal and collaborative creative relationship. Ursula published her debut volume of poetry, No Other Choice, in 1941. Following the death of Ursula’s first husband in 1942, she was invited by Ralph and his wife, Adeline, to live with them, cementing the relationship between the three of them. Ursula published her second volume of poetry, Fall of Leaf, in 1943. Ursula and Ralph were married in 1953 following Adeline’s death in 1951. More tends to be said about Ursula’s relationship with Ralph and her role as his muse than about her own works; however, she was a well-respected author in her own right, and provided texts for other composers, including Herbert Howells, Malcolm Williamson, and Elisabeth Lutyens. In Ralph’s settings of Ursula’s texts we detect not only a perfect synthesis of word and music, but also a relationship of sincere respect and devotion.
The Four Last Songs were set to music by Ralph between 1954-1958, and were originally intended to be divided into two separate song cycles with the addition of other songs. While it has seemed to some that the two songs responding to Greek mythology (I, IV) were intended for one cycle and the other two (II, III), which deal more intimately with romantic love, were intended for the other, there is evidence that Ralph intended a close relationship between III and IV, and perhaps between I and II as well. The text for Procris was originally published as part of Fall of Leaf in 1943, and was inspired by a painting by Piero di Cosimo in the London National Gallery. Before 1951 the painting was titled “The Death of Procris,” as it was thought that it depicted the mythology of Procris from Ovid’s Metamorphoses VII. Confidence that this is the painting’s subject matter has since been shaken, but it was to this mythology that Urula responded in her poem. In Ovid, Procris is murdered by mistake by her husband Cephalus as he is startled by her sudden approach from behind trees, thinking she is a charging wild animal. Procris had been told that Cephalus had been calling for another woman while hunting, but he had in fact been summoning the god of the west wind, Zephyr, to cool him. Procris’s joy in realizing the truth is short-lived, and she dies in Cephalus’ arms. di Cosimo’s painting depicts a dog, a symbol of loyalty, next to the dying Procris, but she tragically dies a victim of her misplaced jealousy. Ursula responded to the darkness of the mythology, describing a world full of life that Procris’s loving eyes, gradually shutting, will never see. Alongside the literal darkness closing around her is a growing spiritual darkness.
Similar images of waning light are found in “Tired”, where a devoted lover remembers holding vigil by their sleeping beloved near a slowly crumbling fire. The poet clings to and lives in this memory as a defence against passing time and waning spiritual strength. “Hands, Eyes, and Heart” is possibly, with its straightforward expression of love and devotion, the most intimate of the four texts, and Ursula seems as such to have been somewhat protective of its musical setting, proscribing that it should only be sung by women. Ralph was more open in his attitude toward the song’s performance, and it has since been sung by both men and women. Ralph intended III as a “pendant” to IV, “Menelaus,” which returns to Greek mythology for its subject matter. Ralph and Ursula sustained as part of their relationship a practice of reading to one another, including especially the Greek classics. Ursula’s text, whose full title is “Menelaus on the Beach at Pharos” was a response to reading with Ralph the T.E. Lawrence (immortalized in Lawrence of Arabia) translation of The Odyssey. While the story of Odysseus’s gradual return to Penelope has recently been reexamined in the popular Zeitgeist, Ursula’s poem responded to Menelaus’s recollection in Book IV of The Odyssey of a speech made to him by Proteus, in which Menelaus was instructed how he was to return to his wife, Helen. Menelaus was told, “from the river of earth the west wind ever sings soft and thrillingly to reanimate the souls of men - there you will have Helen for yourself and will be deemed of the household of Zeus.” The west wind, misunderstood in “Procris,” is here redeemed to guide Menelaus home to Helen. Ursula seems to have responded to The Odyssey’s themes of forgetting and subsequently remembering and returning home, placing Menelaus where the “cold” winds have estranged him from home, and the “horned sea poppies,” associated with sleep and dreams (potentially the imagined counterpart to Odysseus’s lotus flower?), have caused him to forget his home. The warm west wind drives away sleep, returns memories of home, and physically returns Menelaus to a home now changed, but one that embraces him with a sense of belonging deeper than he had known before. The climax of Ralph’s musical setting coincides with the moment of homecoming, as Menelaus is implored to “stretch out your hand,” to leave the ship and take the hand of his beloved who welcomes him home.