× Upcoming Events About Us Meet our Artistic Staff Thank you to our Donors Volunteer Paramount Theatre Past Events
Johannes Brahms (Hamburg, 1833 – Vienna, 1897)
Gesang der Parzen (“Song of the Fates”), Op. 89 (1882)

As a complete contrast, Brahms’s Song of the Fates deals with some very grave matters of life and death.  It is the last of three shorter works for chorus and orchestra in which Brahms dealt with the fragility of the human condition, each based on a poem by a different German classic poet.  After the Schicksalslied (1871, Hölderlin, and the Nänie (1881, Schiller), Brahms in 1882 turned to Goethe’s somber meditation on the subject from his 1786 drama Iphigenia in Tauris.

Iphigenia, daughter of Agamemnon and Clytemnestra, came from a family that had been cursed by the gods for several generations.  The history of the Mycenean royal dynasty was full of horrible murders in which close relatives killed one another with unspeakable cruelty.  At a crucial juncture in her own life, Iphigenia remembers the “Song of the Fates” her nurse used to sing to her when she was a child, about the helplessness of humans in the face of the gods’ whims.  Yet Iphigenia adds an “afterword” to the song, in which she imagines her ancestor Tantalus, whose original sin set all the subsequent tragic events in motion, “shaking his head” at the gods, who won’t stop punishing later generations for the actions of their forefather.

Of the three choral works dealing with human destiny, the Song of the Fates is the darkest.  Brahms placed great emphasis on low-pitched instruments such as the contrabassoon and the bass tuba and often took the bass voices of the chorus to the bottom of their range as well.  The chorus is divided into six parts instead of the usual four, making the choral texture denser and more massive.  When Brahms uses the male and female voices in alternation, each half of the chorus still has three parts, allowing for a richer harmony.  The strong dactylic meter (long-short-short) of Goethe’s text is forcefully hammered home in Brahms’s setting.

There is only one brief section in the entire work where the tension eases somewhat, and this moment has caused some controversy among commentators.  In the penultimate stanza, Goethe speaks about the cruelty of the gods who are indifferent to human suffering, and yet Brahms’s music sounds gentle and soothing.  Musicologist Stephen Luttmann resolved the apparent contradiction, writing on an online platform in 2011:

Brahms’s depiction of the ability (and characteristic) of the gods to turn their eyes away from entire races, and to fail to recognize the features of the once beloved mortal in his grandchildren with a touchingly beautiful choral setting in D major is, in fact, a masterstroke of bitter, devastating irony: So [blithe] and beautiful is indeed the world of the gods, in which they can curse a mortal and his progeny for all eternity.

After this brief intermezzo, the final stanza (Iphigenia’s commentary on the song of the Fates) returns us to the gloomy atmosphere of the beginning.  The ending, when we all may feel like Tantalus and shake our heads, mystified by the gods’ incomprehensible behavior, is one of the most enigmatic passages in all of Brahms.