Act 2
Nobody Cares About Santa
Buddy, Store Manager, Ensemble
Never Fall in Love (With an Elf)
Jovie
There Is a Santa Claus
Michael, Emily
The Story of Buddy
Buddy, Michael, Walter, Ms. Greenway, and Ensemble
Nobody Cares About Santa [Reprise]
Santa
A Christmas Song [Reprise]
Jovie, Buddy, Emily, Michael, Walter, Ensemble
Finale
Ensemble