After enrolling at the Petrograd Conservatory at the age of 13, Dmitri Shostakovich excelled as a piano and composition student while also working a side job as an accompanist for silent films. He completed his education at 19 with a masterful First Symphony as his graduation piece, and soon performances at home and abroad positioned the young Shostakovich as the defining musician of the young Soviet Union.
Then everything changed when Joseph Stalin walked out of Shostakovich’s esoteric new opera in 1936, and an official party newspaper delivered a frightening critique. The 30-year-old star became a pariah, and he proceeded with understandable caution in that time when Stalin’s enemies were disappearing by the thousands. After he completed his Fifth Symphony the next year, no established conductor would even take it on, but a young assistant conductor at the Leningrad Philharmonic agreed to lead the premiere that turned out to be a watershed moment in Shostakovich’s career, capped by a 30-minute ovation.
Two years later, when the same conductor and orchestra took up Shostakovich’s Sixth Symphony, the expectations were enormous. Shostakovich had suggested at one point that it might be a grand tribute to Lenin, complete with chorus and soloists, but instead the new symphony emerged as a purely instrumental work, and one with a relatively subdued tone that, according to Shostakovich, was meant to convey “the moods of spring, joy, youth.”
Considering the climate of paranoia and doublespeak that suffused Soviet life under Stalin, it’s hard to know if we can take Shostakovich at his word. Is it truly an expression of “spring, joy [and] youth” to begin a symphony with a 20-minute rumination in a glacial Largo tempo? This extended slow movement constitutes about two-thirds of the symphony’s unusual structure.
The scherzo follows in an exuberant triplet pulse, filled with dizzying woodwind solos (including a starring role for the bright and chipper E-flat clarinet) and wild blasts that speak to Shostakovich’s knack for cinematic showmanship. The finale maintains maximal forward momentum with a galloping figure that recalls the manic orchestral dashes of Haydn, Mozart and Rossini, especially the latter’s William Tell Overture. There is an explosive hilarity to this music that teeters on the edge of menacing—a fine line that Shostakovich toed brilliantly in the self-protective, multilayered style he mastered for the sake of his own survival.
Piccolo, two flutes, two oboes, English horn, E-flat clarinet, three clarinets, bass clarinet, three bassoons, contrabassoon, four horns, three trumpets, three trombones, tuba, timpani, percussion, harp, celesta, strings